Why New Year's Resolutions Fail, and the 3 Fixes That Work

Published 6 min read

In short

About one person in two is still keeping their resolution six months later (Norcross, 2002): failure is not the rule. Research links better follow-through to three things: framing the goal as a start rather than a stop, an immediate payoff, and a set moment to act.

You have probably dropped a resolution before, maybe several times. That is not a character flaw: research links how well a resolution lasts to how it is framed and started. This guide starts from the research, not from tips, and ends with a method you can start tonight.

How many resolutions actually last?

About half last six months, against almost nobody among people who made none. A New Year's resolution is a commitment made for the new year: to start, stop or change something. Here is what published studies measured.

StudyWhoResultWhen
Norcross, Mrykalo & Blagys (2002)159 people with a resolution, 123 without, followed for 6 months46% of resolvers still successful, against 4% of non-resolvers6 months
Norcross & Vangarelli (1988)200 people followed for 2 years77% last one week, 19% last two years1 week, 2 years
Oscarsson et al. (2020)1,066 people55% judge themselves successful1 year

In the 1988 study, relapses followed stress, negative emotions and loss of control. Sources: Norcross 2002 on PubMed, Norcross & Vangarelli 1988 on PubMed, Oscarsson 2020 in PLOS ONE.

The useful takeaway: close to half of people who make a resolution are still keeping it at six months. These are observations, not an experiment, so they don't prove the resolution alone causes the change. What research links to better follow-through is how the resolution is framed and started.

Why people give up on resolutions: three measured mistakes

Here are three things research links to better follow-through. They are not the only ones, but they are the ones you can act on tonight.

You promise to stop instead of start

In Oscarsson and colleagues' study, 58.9% of approach goals ("do something") were judged successful after a year, against 47.1% of avoidance goals ("stop doing something"). The study compares goals and the success people report; it doesn't prove that rewording alone is enough.

A start gives you a concrete thing to do, where a stop asks you to do nothing: "eat a piece of fruit at 4 p.m." is easier to launch than "stop snacking". When you can, look for an action that takes the place of the stop.

You count on a distant reward

According to Kaitlin Woolley and Ayelet Fishbach (2017), immediate enjoyment predicts persistence better than long-term benefits. A goal that only makes sense months from now has a harder time surviving a rainy Tuesday night.

If you can, choose a version of the habit that feels good right away: music you love, a pleasant place, someone to do it with.

You have a goal, not a first step or a moment

"Get into fitness" is a goal. It doesn't say what to do tomorrow at 7:30. Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer calls a plan of the form "if [situation], then [action]" an implementation intention. A meta-analysis (Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006) found that stating when and where you will act clearly improves goal attainment (a medium-to-large effect, d ≈ 0.65), compared with a plain goal.

The tiny first step and the anchor (something you already do every day: coffee, brushing your teeth, getting home from work) come from a different approach, B.J. Fogg's, which builds on the same idea. For more on this mechanism, read our guide to completing a bucket list.

A 4-step method for this year

Pick one resolution, make its first step tiny, attach it to an anchor, and plan for the day you miss. Here is how.

  1. Pick one resolution, framed as a start. One, not five. If a dream has been waiting for years (a trip, an instrument, a race), it is a good candidate, as long as it is yours and not something you think you ought to want. Browse 400+ dream ideas if you're unsure.
  2. Find its 5-minute first step. The first step is the smallest concrete action that moves you forward. Three examples from the GoDream catalog:
DreamFirst stepTime
Go to JapanWrite down the price of a round-trip flight to Tokyo in the cheapest month5 min
Run a marathonWrite down how many minutes you can run today without stopping5 min
Learn to play the guitarWrite down the three songs you want to be able to play5 min
  1. Attach it to an anchor. "After [daily habit], I [first step]." For example: "After my coffee, I write down the price of a flight to Tokyo."
  2. Make it pleasant right away, and plan the missed day. Once the step is done, mark it: a "done", a ticked box (a technique from B.J. Fogg, not a result of the studies above). Also write your bad-day rule: "if I miss a day, I do the smallest possible step tomorrow." Don't try to catch up.

This is what GoDream does: one dream, one step a day (most take under fifteen minutes) with its anchor, "Smaller" when a step is too big, "Not today" for missed days, a single reminder. The app is on the App Store for iPhone and iPad; on Android, you can join the beta on the site.

What if you already missed January?

Nothing is lost: the fresh start effect isn't limited to January 1st. Hengchen Dai, Katherine Milkman and Jason Riis (2014) found that searches for "diet", gym visits and commitments rise after calendar landmarks: a Monday, the start of a month, a new year, a birthday.

These landmarks are moments when the urge to change rises. The study doesn't measure whether you stick with it better than in January, but if January has passed, a Monday or the start of a month is a good time to restart. As for the slip: in the study by Lally and colleagues (2010), forming a habit took a median of 66 days (from 18 to 254 depending on the person), and missing a day now and then did not stop the habit from forming. The study says nothing about several missed days in a row: the safest move is to resume the next day.

GoDream follows the same principle: a missed day is repaired with the smallest step tomorrow, not with a feeling of failure.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of New Year's resolutions fail?

About half are still going at six months: 46% of people who made a resolution were still keeping it, against 4% of those who hadn't made one (Norcross et al., 2002). Gloomier figures such as "only 8% succeed" have no published study behind them. The result depends on what is measured and for how long.

Why do people give up on resolutions?

Relapses follow stress, negative emotions and loss of control (Norcross & Vangarelli, 1988). Research also links better follow-through to a goal framed as a start, an immediate payoff and a set moment to act. These are leads, not a single cause.

What is a good New Year's resolution?

One that you want and can frame as a start: learning an instrument, running 20 minutes, planning a trip. If a dream has been waiting for a long time, it is a strong place to begin. Browse dream ideas for inspiration.

Is it too late to start a New Year's resolution?

No. January 1st is one landmark among many: Mondays, the start of a month and birthdays also give you a fresh start (Dai, Milkman & Riis, 2014). A landmark can help, but it shouldn't become an excuse: if you can do a five-minute step today, don't wait for it.

How long does it take for a resolution to become a habit?

Longer than the often-quoted "21 days": a median of 66 days, ranging from 18 to 254 depending on the person and the behavior (Lally et al., 2010). Missing a day now and then did not compromise the result, for simple everyday behaviors. Count in months, not weeks.

New Year's resolutionFresh start effectFirst stepImplementation intentionAnchorHabit

Read next

Comment tenir ses bonnes résolutions, selon les études · Cómo cumplir los propósitos de Año Nuevo, según la ciencia · Como cumprir as metas de Ano Novo, segundo a ciência

Your dream, one small step a day

GoDream breaks a dream into small actions, one a day, each tied to a moment of your day. Available on the App Store for iPhone and iPad; Android is in beta.

Android: join the beta

Android: use your Google Play account address (the one on your Play Store, often @gmail.com). Any other address can't be added to the test.

Free beta · no spam. We store your email, platform and browser — learn more.